William Alvarez Bronx Subway Shooting: Three Arrested in Connection with 45-Year-Old Victim’s Death

By | February 28, 2024



– Cause of death determined for man killed on D train in bronx
– Death determined for man killed on D train in bronx.

Accident – Death – Obituary News :

Man Killed in Bronx Subway Fight, Three Arrested

Authorities have determined the cause of death for a man who was fatally shot during a confrontation with three individuals while riding the subway in the Bronx. The victim, identified as 45-year-old William Alvarez of the Bronx, succumbed to a gunshot wound to the chest, as confirmed by the city’s medical examiner, who classified the manner of death as a homicide.

Despite this revelation, unanswered questions linger surrounding the shooting incident that took place aboard the D train just before 5 a.m. on Friday. The motive behind the attack and the trigger that sparked the heated altercation remain unclear. Police have taken three suspects into custody in connection with Alvarez’s tragic death: 24-year-old Justin Herde, 38-year-old Betty Cotto, and 42-year-old Alfredo Trinidad.

The specific charges against the trio have not been disclosed, and their relationship to each other as well as to the victim remains uncertain. Legal representation for the suspects is currently unavailable.

Arrest of Alfredo Trinidad

An authoritative figure within law enforcement revealed that Alfredo Trinidad was found in possession of a firearm at the time of his apprehension on Sunday night at an apartment on Villa Avenue, where he was accompanied by his girlfriend and her brother.


According to the New York Police Department (NYPD), Alvarez was travelling on the southbound D train when the three suspects boarded at Fordham Road. An altercation ensued after one of the suspects seated themselves next to Alvarez, leading to a physical altercation that escalated when the other two suspects joined in, resulting in a three-on-one confrontation, as per NYPD Transit Chief Michael Kemper. The train eventually halted at the 182nd-183rd streets stop, where the three suspects fled the scene.

Upon arrival at Grand Concourse, law enforcement was alerted to the situation and discovered the victim unconscious. Emergency responders swiftly transported Alvarez to St. Barnabas Hospital, where he was pronounced deceased. No weapon was recovered at the crime scene initially, and the whereabouts of the suspects were unknown following their escape. Authorities mentioned that surveillance footage captured within the train carriage depicting the entire altercation could play a pivotal role in their ongoing investigation.


The NYPD had been searching three individuals, two men and a woman (above) in connection with the death of a subway rider in the Bronx. All three have since been arrested.

This incident is the latest in a series of violent occurrences within the subway system. Notably, on February 12th, six individuals sustained gunshot wounds on the platform at the Mt. Eden Avenue subway station in the Bronx, where teenagers engaged in a gunfire exchange resulting in the tragic death of a 35-year-old.

Recent statistics from the NYPD reveal a concerning trend, with 2023 recording the highest number of subway assaults since at least 1996. Throughout that year, there were 570 reported assaults, indicating a slight uptick from the previous year and averaging approximately 1.5 incidents daily.

Despite these disheartening figures, Kemper expressed optimism in the progress being made. The deployment of an additional 1,000 officers to the subway system, a direct response to a surge in crime in January, has contributed to a 17% reduction in criminal activities in February (though the overall crime rate for the year remains 13% higher than in 2023). Kemper referred to the high-profile fatalities as “isolated incidents” without divulging further specifics.

“We are dedicated to sustaining this forward momentum,” Kemper affirmed. “Our officers are actively present, visible, and under significant pressure as they tackle their challenging responsibilities.”

Authorities continue to grapple with identifying the weapon used in the victim’s demise. Journalist Myles Miller from News 4 conducted an investigative report on the ongoing investigation.

Kemper, alongside transit officials, attributed the surge in subway-related crimes to recurrent offenders with lengthy criminal records. MTA President Richard Davey disclosed that seven assaults against transit workers had been documented in 2024, resulting in the arrest of four suspects with a cumulative history of 50 prior arrests.

“I implore the judicial system to ensure that appropriate justice is served,” Davey emphasised. “Fifty strikes seem excessively lenient.”

MTA Chairman Janno Lieber highlighted the underutilisation of a new punitive measure available for individuals who assault transit employees: a ban on utilizing mass transit services within the city.


– cause of death determined for man killed on d train in bronx
– man killed on d train in bronx, cause of death determined.