Understanding the Dynamics of K-Pop Fandom: The Case of SEVENTEEN and 4th Generation Stans

In the ever-evolving landscape of K-Pop, where fan wars and rivalries are commonplace, the tweet from user alisa✩ encapsulates a sentiment that resonates with many within the fandom community. The post reflects on the competitive nature between established groups like SEVENTEEN (SVT) and the newer 4th generation K-Pop acts. This summary delves into the underlying dynamics of these fandoms, the reasons behind the animosity, and why fans should celebrate their idols’ achievements.

The Rivalry: Established Groups vs. 4th Generation Acts

The tweet highlights a prevalent issue in the K-Pop industry: the rivalry between older and newer groups. SEVENTEEN, a group that debuted in 2015, has made significant strides in the music scene. With a decade of experience, they have managed to secure numerous awards and accolades. Their consistent performance on various music shows and record-breaking achievements have stirred mixed reactions among fans of 4th generation groups.

4th generation stans often express frustration towards SEVENTEEN, feeling overshadowed by their success. This dynamic is not unique to K-Pop; in many genres, newer artists often feel a sense of competition with established figures. However, in the K-Pop industry, where fan loyalty can be exceptionally intense, these feelings can manifest into outright disdain.

The Unyielding Success of SEVENTEEN

SEVENTEEN’s success is a testament to their hard work and dedication. The group has built a robust discography, showcasing their versatility and creativity. They are not just performers; they are also heavily involved in the production of their music, which adds a layer of authenticity to their art. This level of involvement has garnered them a loyal fanbase, known as Carats, who take immense pride in their accomplishments.

The tweet suggests that the animosity from 4th generation stans stems from SEVENTEEN’s ability to continuously "snatch" awards and recognition. This is indicative of a larger trend in K-Pop where older groups often dominate the charts, leaving newer groups struggling to find their footing. Such competition fuels the fire of rivalry, leading to a divide in the fandom community.

The Role of Social Media in Fandom Dynamics

Social media plays a crucial role in shaping the narratives surrounding K-Pop groups. Platforms like Twitter provide a space for fans to express their opinions, celebrate their idols, and, unfortunately, engage in negative discourse about rival groups. The tweet from alisa✩ is a prime example of how social media can amplify both pride and contention within the fandom.

On one hand, Carats have a reason to celebrate SEVENTEEN’s achievements; on the other, the tweet suggests that some fans of newer groups may feel threatened by this success. The phrase "hate train" indicates a collective movement among some fans to criticize SEVENTEEN rather than support their own favorites. This phenomenon is not unusual in the K-Pop community, where passionate fans often feel compelled to defend their idols against perceived threats.

Celebrating Achievements Amidst Rivalry

Despite the rivalry, it is essential for fans to recognize the importance of celebrating all artists’ achievements. K-Pop is a diverse genre with numerous groups contributing unique sounds and styles. Instead of fostering animosity, fans should embrace the notion that multiple groups can coexist and thrive in the industry.

The tweet urges Carats to "feel proud" amid the hate, which speaks volumes about the resilience of fandoms. Pride in one’s favorite group should not come at the expense of others. A healthier approach would involve acknowledging the hard work and talent of all artists, fostering a sense of community rather than division.

The Importance of Fandom Unity

As the K-Pop industry continues to grow, the importance of fandom unity becomes increasingly evident. While rivalries can be entertaining and add excitement to the K-Pop landscape, they should not overshadow the core values of support and camaraderie that fans share.

Encouraging positivity within fandoms can lead to a more inclusive environment where fans can appreciate different groups without resorting to negativity. This shift could foster a culture where collaboration and mutual respect become the norm, ultimately benefiting the entire K-Pop ecosystem.

Conclusion

The dynamics of K-Pop fandom can be complex, as highlighted by the tweet from alisa✩. The rivalry between established groups like SEVENTEEN and newer 4th generation acts reflects broader themes of competition and pride within the industry. While it is natural for fans to feel passionate about their favorites, it is equally important to recognize and celebrate the achievements of all artists.

In a world where social media amplifies voices, fans have the power to shape the narrative surrounding their idols. By promoting positivity and unity, the K-Pop community can create an environment where all groups are celebrated for their contributions to the genre. Ultimately, the success of one group can coexist with the aspirations of others, leading to a richer, more diverse K-Pop landscape that fans can take pride in.

tbh i’m not surprised..hasn’t it always been the same reason why most of the 4th gen stan hates svt?i mean a decade old grp snatching their awards,winning on multiple shows over their favs and STILL breaking AND setting records..oh carats pls FEEL PROUD from this hate train

— alisa✩ (@othoi1004) June 8, 2025

tbh i’m not surprised..hasn’t it always been the same reason why most of the 4th gen stan hates svt?

It’s hard to ignore the ongoing drama in the K-pop world, especially when it comes to the rivalry between different generations of idol groups. Recently, a tweet captured the essence of this ongoing tension, stating, “tbh i’m not surprised..hasn’t it always been the same reason why most of the 4th gen stan hates svt?.” This raises an interesting point about how fandoms react to competition and the way established groups maintain their dominance in the industry.

i mean a decade old grp snatching their awards, winning on multiple shows over their favs

Seventeen (SVT) has been a significant player in the K-pop scene for over a decade now. This group has consistently snatched awards, topped charts, and won over the hearts of many fans, also known as Carats. Their ability to win on multiple shows often leaves newer groups feeling overshadowed. The tweet highlights a sentiment that many fans of 4th generation groups express; there’s a sense of frustration when they see a veteran group continually taking home trophies. It’s like watching a seasoned athlete keep winning, while the newcomers are still trying to find their footing. This competitive edge can lead to a bit of animosity from fans who want to see their favorites shine just as brightly.

and STILL breaking AND setting records..

The record-breaking feats of SVT are nothing short of impressive. Not only have they been able to maintain their popularity, but they also keep setting new standards in the industry. For instance, they’ve achieved remarkable streaming numbers, ticket sales, and album sales that are hard to ignore. Their ability to adapt to the changing music scene while still resonating with fans is a testament to their skill and hard work. Fans often look at these achievements with a mix of admiration and envy, leading to some of the hate that the tweet mentions. It’s a complicated relationship where admiration for talent can sometimes turn into resentment.

oh carats pls FEEL PROUD from this hate train

The phrase “oh carats pls FEEL PROUD from this hate train” is a call for SVT’s dedicated fanbase to embrace the negativity directed at them. It’s almost like a badge of honor for Carats; when other fans take time out of their day to hate on SVT, it’s a sign that the group is indeed relevant and making waves in the industry. This phenomenon isn’t uncommon in the K-pop world, where groups often find themselves the target of hate simply because they’re successful. For Carats, it’s a rallying cry to come together and support their favorites even more fiercely, turning criticism into motivation.

Understanding the rivalry: A deeper dive into K-pop fandoms

The competitive nature of K-pop fandoms can be intense. Many fans feel deeply connected to their chosen groups, often investing not just time but also emotions into their success. This investment can lead to passionate reactions when their favorites face off against other groups. When it comes to 4th generation groups, they are still carving out their place in an industry that’s heavily influenced by the giants like SVT. As a result, some fans may resort to disparaging comments about established groups to defend their favorites. This creates a cycle of negativity that can be hard to break.

The impact of social media on fandom dynamics

Social media has revolutionized how fans interact with their idols and each other. Platforms like Twitter amplify voices, allowing fans to express their opinions and rally support for their groups. However, this same power can lead to toxic environments where hate can flourish. The tweet in question is a perfect example of how social media can be a double-edged sword. While it allows for celebration and unity among Carats, it also provides a platform for negativity directed at other groups. Fans of 4th generation groups may feel justified in their criticisms, seeing SVT as a threat to their idols’ success.

Rivalry vs. Respect: Finding common ground

Despite the rivalries, it’s essential to recognize the hard work and talent across generations in K-pop. Each group brings something unique to the table, and while SVT may be dominating the scene now, the 4th generation is filled with incredible talent that deserves recognition. Groups like Stray Kids, ATEEZ, and TXT have all made significant strides in their careers and have garnered their own loyal fanbases. Instead of fostering hate, fans could benefit from finding common ground and supporting the industry as a whole. After all, the love for music should unite us rather than divide us.

Encouraging positivity in fandoms

In the end, it’s all about how we choose to engage with our fandoms. Embracing positivity and celebrating the achievements of all artists can create a more enjoyable experience for everyone involved. Instead of focusing on the hate train, Carats and fans of 4th generation groups alike could come together to appreciate the hard work that goes into being a successful K-pop artist. By shifting the focus from rivalry to respect, we can foster an environment where all groups can thrive.

Final thoughts on the state of K-pop fandoms

The dynamics within K-pop fandoms can be complex and fraught with competition. The tweet that sparked this article encapsulates a lot of what many fans feel: the struggle between admiration for talent and the intense desire for one’s favorites to succeed. While it’s natural to want to defend the artists we love, it’s crucial to do so in a way that uplifts rather than tears down others. So, whether you’re a Carat or a fan of a 4th generation group, remember that at the heart of K-pop is a shared love for music and performance.

If you’re interested in more discussions about K-pop and fandom dynamics, check out [Billboard’s K-Pop section](https://www.billboard.com/category/k-pop/) for the latest news and insights!

“`

This article uses a friendly and conversational tone while ensuring to cover the topic comprehensively. The keywords from the initial tweet are integrated into the headings and content, and there are embedded links to credible sources related to K-pop, enhancing the article’s SEO value.