Bob Sullivan : “Web of Lies: Identifying Strands for Truth”

By Bob Sullivan

In a recent column, I discussed the importance of reliable resources in understanding and defending our Catholic faith. However, amidst the abundance of information available, we must remain vigilant as there are sources specifically designed to mislead us. As warned in Matthew 7:15, false prophets may present themselves as harmless, but they are driven by ulterior motives.

While it is unfortunate when anti-Catholics spread misinformation, it becomes more troubling when Catholics themselves intentionally distort the truth. Jesus warned about such individuals in Matthew 7, stating that false prophets would face dire consequences. It is essential, therefore, to discern between truth and misinformation.

So, how can we determine if we are being presented with accurate information or a warped version of the truth? Matthew 7 offers guidance by focusing on the fruits produced by a resource. By examining the conversions, repentance, virtue, holiness, peace, joy, and healing that result from a particular source, we can assess its credibility.

On the other hand, misinformation often appears attractive but contains a small percentage of deceit. Propaganda is a prime example of this, as it typically consists of mostly true information with a small, misleading component. Just as a trace of polonium-210 can turn a seemingly harmless cup of tea deadly, even a minute amount of misinformation can have severe consequences.

Identifying misinformation becomes more challenging when it originates from individuals we trust or those who present themselves as devout Catholics. This is why it is crucial for parents and high school students to have access to resources like the Newman Guide, which recognizes reliable Catholic colleges and universities.

Instances of misinformation within Catholic institutions are not uncommon. St. Mary’s College, for example, recently considered accepting male students who identified as female, causing shock among many Catholics. Similarly, a Notre Dame professor filed a defamation lawsuit against a Catholic school newspaper for publishing her pro-abortion advocacy. Fortunately, the lawsuit was dismissed, as the newspaper had published the truth. Loyola Marymount University also raised concerns when it allowed a student club to host a fundraiser for Planned Parenthood, a prominent abortion provider.

For young Catholics and those less familiar with Catholic teachings, Scripture, and Christian history, even a small amount of misinformation can be detrimental to their faith. Misleading information from priests, nuns, or individuals who claim to be devout Catholics only exacerbates the confusion. To counter this, it is essential to have a solid understanding of the Catholic faith’s teachings, especially on contemporary issues.

Amidst the sea of Catholic resources available today, discerning the reliable from the unreliable can be challenging. However, starting with well-established sources such as your diocese and EWTN can lead you to other credible sources. With an abundance of proven Catholic resources at our disposal, there is no need to seek information on the Catholic faith from non-Catholic religions or sources.