The tweet shared by Mr. Sinha quotes the ancient Indian philosopher Chanakya, who lived around 300 BC. The quote suggests that a child born to a foreign woman will never be loyal to their nation and will always seek to benefit its enemies. This provocative statement raises questions about the concept of loyalty and patriotism, especially in a globalized world where people often have multicultural backgrounds.

The tweet has sparked a debate on social media, with some users agreeing with Chanakya’s assertion and others condemning it as discriminatory and xenophobic. The idea that one’s nationality is determined by their parentage is a contentious issue, as many people believe that loyalty to a nation is a matter of choice and commitment rather than bloodline.

Chanakya was known for his pragmatic and often ruthless approach to politics, and his writings continue to be studied and debated in modern times. While some may see his views as outdated and narrow-minded, others argue that there may be some truth to the idea that one’s upbringing and cultural influences can shape their loyalties and allegiances.

Overall, this tweet serves as a reminder of the complex nature of identity and belonging, and the ways in which historical ideas can still resonate in contemporary discussions about nationalism and citizenship. It is important to critically examine and challenge such statements, while also acknowledging the historical context in which they were made.

A child born from a foreign woman can never be faithful to the nation, he/she will always try to benefit the enemies – Chanakya (300 BC) pic.twitter.com/f3CfSVj8kf

— Mr Sinha (@MrSinha_) May 19, 2025

When it comes to discussing the loyalty of individuals born from foreign parents, controversy often arises. In a tweet that recently went viral, Chanakya, an ancient Indian philosopher from 300 BC, expressed the opinion that a child born from a foreign woman can never be faithful to the nation. According to him, such individuals will always try to benefit the enemies. This statement has sparked a heated debate online, with many people questioning its validity and relevance in today’s multicultural society.

It is essential to examine the context in which Chanakya made this statement. During his time, India was facing constant invasions and threats from foreign powers. Therefore, his concerns about loyalty and allegiance were deeply rooted in the political and social realities of that era. However, in today’s globalized world, where people from different backgrounds coexist and interact on a daily basis, the notion that one’s birth determines their loyalty seems outdated and discriminatory.

One must consider that loyalty is not a trait inherited at birth but rather a value that is nurtured and developed over time. People’s sense of loyalty is shaped by their upbringing, experiences, and personal beliefs. It is unfair to make blanket assumptions about an individual’s loyalty based solely on their parentage or nationality.

Furthermore, the idea that individuals born from foreign parents are more likely to betray their nation is not supported by empirical evidence. Countless examples exist of immigrants and their descendants who have shown unwavering loyalty and dedication to their adopted countries. Many immigrants have made significant contributions to their new homelands, serving in the military, excelling in various professions, and actively participating in civic life.

It is crucial to recognize the diversity and richness that immigrants bring to a nation. They often bring new perspectives, skills, and ideas that can benefit society as a whole. By embracing diversity and fostering inclusivity, countries can harness the full potential of their multicultural populations and build stronger, more cohesive communities.

In conclusion, while Chanakya’s perspective on the loyalty of individuals born from foreign parents may have been relevant in ancient times, it does not hold true in today’s world. Loyalty is a complex and multifaceted concept that cannot be reduced to one’s birth or heritage. Instead of perpetuating divisive narratives, we should strive to promote unity, understanding, and respect for all individuals, regardless of their background. Embracing diversity is not a sign of weakness but a strength that enriches our societies and paves the way for a more inclusive and harmonious future.