Death- Obituary news

Analyzing Criticism of Writing in Naruto: The Case of Sasuke and Kirin

The world of anime and manga is rich with complex characters, intricate plots, and unique powers, but it is not without its criticisms. One such critique emerged recently in a tweet discussing the character Sasuke Uchiha from the widely popular series "Naruto." The tweet highlights a perceived inconsistency in the series regarding Sasuke’s use of the jutsu Kirin, raising questions about the writing quality of creator Masashi Kishimoto. This article will delve into the specific points raised in the tweet, the implications for character development, and the broader conversation about writing quality in "Naruto."

Understanding Sasuke’s Kirin Jutsu

Kirin is a powerful lightning-based jutsu that Sasuke Uchiha uses during the series. However, its usage requires specific environmental conditions—namely, the presence of storm clouds to generate the necessary lightning. The tweet asserts that Sasuke’s ability to utilize Kirin without proper preparation contradicts the established rules of the jutsu, suggesting that Kishimoto prioritized making Sasuke appear impressive over adhering to logical consistency.

This criticism points to a larger issue within "Naruto": the balance between character development and the constraints of the narrative. While it’s common for shonen anime to feature characters who evolve and showcase new abilities, the believability of these abilities is crucial for maintaining audience engagement. In Sasuke’s case, the inconsistency surrounding Kirin could be seen as a failure to uphold the internal logic of the series.

The Importance of Internal Logic in Storytelling

When crafting a story, especially in genres like fantasy or science fiction, maintaining internal logic is paramount. Audiences appreciate when the rules established within the world are respected. If a character can suddenly perform a powerful technique without the necessary prerequisites, it can lead to viewer dissatisfaction and questions about the overall quality of the writing.

In this instance, the tweet argues that Kishimoto’s decision to have Sasuke perform Kirin "off the rip" undermines the narrative structure. Critics argue that such inconsistencies can detract from character depth and the stakes within the story. If characters can defy established abilities without explanation, it diminishes tension and reduces the impact of their actions.

Character Development vs. Narrative Convenience

In the realm of storytelling, character development and narrative convenience often find themselves at odds. Sasuke’s character arc is one of growth, struggle, and ultimately redemption. As a central figure in "Naruto," his evolution is crucial to the overarching narrative. However, as the series progresses, some fans argue that Kishimoto occasionally sacrifices logical consistency for the sake of spectacle.

The desire to create visually striking moments can lead to scenarios where characters perform seemingly impossible feats. In Sasuke’s case, the ability to summon Kirin without the necessary weather conditions may have been an attempt to showcase his power at a pivotal moment. Still, it raises questions: Should character development take precedence over narrative rules? Or should writers be held accountable for maintaining the integrity of their world-building?

The Role of Audience Expectations

Fans of "Naruto" have varying expectations based on their engagement with the series. Long-time viewers often invest emotionally in characters and their journeys, making them more sensitive to inconsistencies. When Sasuke uses Kirin in a way that defies the established logic, it can lead to disappointment among dedicated fans who expect continuity and coherence.

Moreover, the impact of social media on viewer reactions cannot be understated. Platforms like Twitter have become spaces for fans to express their opinions, critique writing choices, and engage in discussions about their favorite series. The tweet in question exemplifies this trend, serving as a microcosm of broader conversations about the quality of writing in "Naruto."

Navigating Criticism and Appreciation

While the tweet points out a specific flaw in the portrayal of Sasuke and Kirin, it’s essential to acknowledge the multitude of factors that contribute to the overall success of "Naruto." The series is celebrated for its rich character development, intricate plotlines, and emotional resonance. Despite occasional inconsistencies, many fans remain deeply connected to the story and its characters.

Criticism can serve as a valuable tool for creators, encouraging them to reflect on their storytelling choices. Acknowledging flaws does not diminish the achievements of "Naruto" but rather highlights the nuanced relationship between creators and their audience. As discussions around writing quality continue, they can foster a deeper understanding of the storytelling process and the challenges that come with it.

Conclusion

The tweet discussing Sasuke’s use of Kirin in "Naruto" raises pertinent questions about writing quality, internal logic, and character development. While it highlights a specific inconsistency, it also opens the door for broader conversations about narrative choices in anime and manga. As fans engage with the series, their critiques can serve to enhance the overall discourse surrounding storytelling, reminding creators of the importance of maintaining consistency and depth in their narratives.

Ultimately, "Naruto" remains a beloved series with a rich legacy, reflecting both its strengths and weaknesses. The ongoing dialogue among fans ensures that the series will continue to be analyzed, celebrated, and critiqued for years to come. As viewers, it is crucial to appreciate the artistry of storytelling while also holding creators accountable for the worlds they build.

this is proof that Naruto has poor writing because Kirin literally needs prep for sasuke to do, so how the fuck was he about to do a jutsu off the rip that clearly needs a weather element to occur? kishimoto just wanted sasuke to look cool for no reason https://t.co/xdCk98osRZ

— dead (@_xnes) April 28, 2025

Understanding the Critique: Naruto’s Writing Flaws

It’s no secret that anime and manga enthusiasts can be quite passionate about their favorite series. One series that often garners a mix of admiration and criticism is *Naruto*. Recently, a Twitter user sparked a conversation about the series’ writing quality, particularly focusing on Sasuke’s jutsu, Kirin. The tweet reads, “this is proof that Naruto has poor writing because Kirin literally needs prep for Sasuke to do, so how the fuck was he about to do a jutsu off the rip that clearly needs a weather element to occur? kishimoto just wanted sasuke to look cool for no reason.” This statement encapsulates a common sentiment among fans who question some of the plot mechanics within the series. Let’s dive deeper into this critique and explore the implications it has on the overall narrative of *Naruto*.

Kirin: The Jutsu that Raises Questions

Kirin is an advanced lightning-based jutsu that Sasuke Uchiha uses during battles. What makes this jutsu particularly interesting is that it requires specific environmental conditions to be executed effectively. As stated in the tweet, it “literally needs prep,” which means that Sasuke can’t just summon it at will without the appropriate atmospheric conditions. This raises an important question: how is it that Sasuke seemingly conjures this jutsu off the rip during a crucial battle?

When we analyze the context of the fight, it’s evident that there’s a significant narrative leap being made. The show often showcases Sasuke in high-stakes battles where he pulls off incredible moves with dramatic flair. However, this sometimes comes at the expense of logical consistency. The fact that Kirin requires a weather element creates a disconnect when Sasuke uses it without any apparent preparation, leading to the perception of poor writing.

The Role of Preparation in Jutsu Execution

In the world of *Naruto*, preparation is a vital component for many jutsus, especially the more complex ones. Characters like Kakashi and Naruto often strategize and set the stage before unleashing their most powerful techniques. This strategic element adds depth to the battles and allows for thrilling moments of suspense.

However, when Sasuke uses Kirin without the necessary preparation, it feels like a plot device rather than a well-thought-out moment. This inconsistency can be frustrating for viewers who appreciate the intricacies of battle tactics and the rules governing jutsu. The moment can come off as a classic case of “style over substance,” where the desire to make a character look cool overshadows the established mechanics of the story.

Kishimoto’s Artistic Choices

Masashi Kishimoto, the creator of *Naruto*, has a unique storytelling style that often prioritizes dramatic moments and character development over strict adherence to the established rules of the ninja world. This has led to some of the most memorable scenes in anime history, but it has also resulted in criticisms similar to those outlined in the tweet.

The choice to have Sasuke use Kirin in an unconventional manner may have been a deliberate attempt to showcase his growth as a character or to heighten the tension in a pivotal moment. However, such choices can alienate fans who are invested in the logical framework of the narrative. The irony lies in the fact that Kishimoto’s intention to make Sasuke look cool could ultimately undermine the story’s credibility.

The Impact of Cool Factor vs. Logic

When analyzing narratives in any medium, the balance between what looks good and what makes sense is often a tightrope walk. In *Naruto*, there’s a significant focus on each character’s “cool factor”—their ability to perform jaw-dropping moves that captivate the audience. While this is a hallmark of shonen anime, it can lead to inconsistencies if not handled carefully.

Sasuke’s portrayal is a prime example of this struggle. He’s designed to be the brooding anti-hero, and moments like the unexpected use of Kirin add to his mystique. However, these moments can also detract from the overall narrative cohesion. The line drawn between making a character appear formidable and maintaining a logical progression can sometimes become blurred, leading to a frustrating experience for viewers who crave a well-structured story.

Fans’ Reactions: A Mixed Bag

The reaction to Sasuke’s use of Kirin has been mixed. Some fans appreciate the visual spectacle and the intense drama that comes with such moments, while others, like the Twitter user whose post sparked this discussion, feel that it undermines the integrity of the story. This dichotomy is common within fandoms, where differing opinions can lead to passionate debates about storytelling techniques.

Critics often point out that these inconsistencies detract from character development and world-building. For example, if a character can perform powerful jutsus without proper conditions, it raises questions about the rules governing the world they inhabit. This can lead to a sense of disillusionment among fans who expect a certain level of adherence to the established lore of the series.

Conclusion: The Balance Between Style and Substance

Ultimately, the critique of Sasuke’s use of Kirin exemplifies a broader issue within *Naruto* and, by extension, many shonen series. The balance between style and substance is a delicate one, and when that balance tips too far toward spectacle, it can lead to perceived flaws in storytelling.

While Kishimoto’s aim to make Sasuke look cool is evident, it’s crucial for fans to consider how such choices impact the overall narrative. As with any long-running series, the evolution of characters and their abilities can lead to inconsistencies, and it’s up to the audience to decide how much they’re willing to overlook in exchange for compelling storytelling.

In the end, the conversation sparked by tweets like the one discussed here is essential for the fandom. It encourages critical thinking about the series and invites discussions that can lead to a deeper appreciation of the storytelling craft, even amidst its flaws. *Naruto* may have its writing quirks, but it remains a beloved series that continues to engage and inspire fans around the world.