Cold Case Closed: Six-Decade-Old Homicide of Daisy Shelton Resolved

Accident – Death – Obituary News : : 1. Ohio cold case solved dismembered woman 1964
2. Gravel pit canal channel murder Ohio 1964 case closed

Authorities in Ohio have officially closed the case on a six-decade-old homicide of a woman whose remains were discovered in a gravel pit and canal channel in Troy. Miami County Prosecutor Anthony Kendall approved closing the case based on information from a key witness and statements from a suspect, both of whom have since passed away. The victim, Daisy Evelyn Shelton, was brutally murdered in 1964, with her dismembered body found in various bodies of water near Tipp City. Despite the challenges of cold-case investigations, authorities believe in the importance of seeking justice for the victim’s family, even if it comes years after the crime occurred.

The Gruesome Murder in Troy, Ohio

In a small town in Ohio, a brutal murder case that had remained unsolved for over six decades has finally been closed. The incident took place in Troy, Ohio, where the remains of Daisy Shelton were found in a gravel pit and a canal channel.

The Discovery of the Remains

The chilling discovery began in June of 1964, when a fisherman stumbled upon a severed human arm in a gravel pit east of Tipp City. Just four days later, another fisherman found a burlap bag in a channel of the old Miami Erie canal containing a dismembered human torso. The investigation revealed that a head and leg were later found in the canal, leading authorities to identify the remains as those of 43-year old Daisy Evelyn Shelton of Dayton.

A Shocking Confession and Revelation

Despite the case going cold for many years, a breakthrough came in 2017 when a key witness, fearing his impending death, confessed to a nurse in a hospital. The witness revealed that he had seen someone kill Shelton by hitting her in the head with a hammer at a Dayton home. He provided crucial information about the disposal of Shelton’s body in bodies of water in and around Tipp City.

The Investigation and Closure

Following the witness’s confession, detectives interviewed a suspect who initially denied knowing Shelton. However, in August 2017, the suspect reluctantly admitted to having known the victim and acknowledged that his house was used to carry her remains. Despite pointing the finger at the eyewitness of the crime, the suspect admitted his potential guilt and the possibility of being convicted in court.

Bringing Closure to a Cold Case

The witness testified before a grand jury, but sadly passed away before the case could be prosecuted. The suspect also died in September of 2022 at the age of ninety-two, closing the chapter on this long-standing mystery. The Miami County sheriff’s office emphasised the importance of revisiting cold-case homicides to bring a sense of justice to the victim’s family, even if it comes long after the crime occurred.

Overall, the closure of this decades-old homicide in Troy, Ohio, serves as a reminder of the tireless efforts of law enforcement in seeking justice for victims and their families.