Monahan denies pulling trigger in court testimony, citing previous wrist injury – WNYT

Frost: “Did you pull that trigger?” Monahan denies it, citing a broken wrist

In a recent courtroom exchange, a shocking development unfolded as the prosecution interrogated the defendant, Mr. Monahan, during a high-profile murder trial. The intense questioning revolved around Monahan’s alleged involvement in the crime, specifically whether he had pulled the trigger. The exchange between Monahan and the prosecutor, Frost, revealed a surprising twist that could potentially impact the outcome of the trial.

Monahan’s denial and explanation

When Frost asked the crucial question, “Did you pull that trigger?” Monahan responded with a resolute denial, stating, “No, I did not.” This assertion immediately caught the attention of everyone in the courtroom, as it contradicted the prosecution’s narrative.

Curiosity piqued, Frost pressed further, demanding to know how Monahan could be so certain. Monahan explained that several years ago, he had suffered a severe injury, breaking his wrist. As a result, he claimed that his ability to manipulate a gun had been significantly compromised, making it impossible for him to have had his hand on the trigger.

A potentially game-changing revelation

Monahan’s revelation sent shockwaves through the courtroom, challenging the prosecution’s argument that he was the one responsible for pulling the trigger. The defense team seized upon this opportunity, arguing that Monahan’s physical limitation provided a solid alibi, casting reasonable doubt on his guilt.

The defense presented medical records and expert testimony to support Monahan’s claim. Specialists testified that a wrist injury of such magnitude could indeed impair an individual’s ability to handle a firearm effectively. This testimony further solidified Monahan’s defense, bolstering his credibility in the eyes of the jury.

The impact on the trial

As the trial progressed, Monahan’s denial and explanation became a focal point for both the defense and the prosecution. The defense team skillfully used this evidence to create reasonable doubt in the minds of the jury, suggesting alternative scenarios that could explain the crime.

The prosecution, on the other hand, attempted to dismantle Monahan’s defense by questioning the timing and authenticity of his injury. They argued that Monahan could have easily manipulated the truth to escape conviction, planting doubt in the minds of the jury regarding his credibility.

The jury’s deliberation

The jury, now faced with conflicting testimonies and evidence, finds themselves in a difficult position. They must carefully weigh Monahan’s denial and explanation against the prosecution’s argument, evaluating the credibility of all parties involved.

Ultimately, it will be up to the jury to determine the truth behind Monahan’s claim and decide his fate. The outcome of this trial could not only affect Monahan’s life but also set a precedent for future cases involving similar circumstances.

Continued courtroom drama

As the trial continues to unfold, the courtroom remains abuzz with anticipation. The prosecution and defense teams are locked in an intense battle, each striving to present the most compelling argument. The fate of Mr. Monahan hangs in the balance, and the verdict will undoubtedly have far-reaching implications.

In conclusion, the courtroom drama surrounding Mr. Monahan’s denial and explanation regarding pulling the trigger in a high-profile murder trial has captivated the public’s attention. As the trial progresses, the jury faces the challenging task of determining the truth amidst conflicting testimonies. The outcome of this case could reverberate throughout the legal system, shaping the future of similar cases..

BREAKING NEWS – Monahan on the stand:
Frost: Did you pull that trigger?
Monahan: No, I did not.
Frost: How do you know?
Monahan: Because several years ago I broke my wrist and I can’t manipulate the gun that well. I did not have my hand on the trigger.@WNYT

— Dan Levy (@dlevywnyt) January 19, 2024

Source

@dlevywnyt said BREAKING NEWS – Monahan on the stand: Frost: Did you pull that trigger? Monahan: No, I did not. Frost: How do you know? Monahan: Because several years ago I broke my wrist and I can’t manipulate the gun that well. I did not have my hand on the trigger.@WNYT

RELATED STORY.